THE horse sport world has to “walk the talk” and show collaborative joined-up thinking to ensure involving horses in sport continues into the future.
Experts discussed the topic “Will we be riding in 20 years’ time?” at a webinar organised by the Showing Council on 17 March. H&H has reported extensively on social licence; essentially public acceptance of horses’ being ridden and taking part in equestrian sport, and the real threat of that being lost.
Showing Council chair Jane Nixon said that the internet allows people all over the world to watch more horse sport than ever, which means it is under huge public scrutiny, often by an audience that is not familiar with the equestrian world.
She pointed out rulings that have been made in other countries; jump racing is banned in many Australian states, there have been demonstrations at events in Germany and protestors ran into the ring at the 2019 European Showjumping Championships.
“Public exposure of any harm will only increase,” she said.
Dr Nixon said one key is producing horses who are fit for purpose; conformationally sound and properly handled and trained from the start to ensure they are suitable for certain careers.
“It’s vital to have a clear picture of what the problem is,” she said. “An increasing proportion of western media believe the horse shouldn’t be ridden at all, on ethical, physical and mental grounds. This challenge isn’t new, but its scope and rate of change have increased massively.”
Dr Nixon added that the industry must respect the views of those who feel it is morally wrong to ride, but another group, who feel the horse is compromised physically and mentally by being ridden, are a different matter.
“We need to change our mindset to challenge the status quo,” she added. “To make changes where justified, even if that’s difficult or needs investment in research to prove evidence-based decision-making.”
It was stressed, as it has been previously, that key to social licence is not only horse welfare being the top priority at all times, but also demonstrating this to the public. In the panel discussion that followed Dr Nixon’s talk, it was asked whether social licence only involves a small section of society, as “most of the public don’t have views on horses and whether they should be ridden”.
But Beverley racecourse CEO Sally Iggulden said: “I think that’s a very dangerous assumption, that it doesn’t matter to people; you can see it’s already happening. You only have to look at the Olympics to see horse sport, on the biggest sporting stage in the world, is under pressure. Will it be included in future years?
“Everyone has an opinion on animal welfare and that’s what this comes down to. We should never underestimate the ability of things to build up a head of steam and we must take this very seriously.”
The possibility of tack checks was raised and supported by panellists, to ensure and show that horses and ponies are comfortable.
World Horse Welfare CEO Roly Owers said racing has introduced pre-run trot-ups at some meetings, adding: “As well as having the hearts and minds of the people, I think there’s a communication aspect. It may well change behaviour, so people don’t run a horse that isn’t quite right, and if people know tack will be checked, it might mean long-term behaviour change.”
The importance of education was stressed, as was communication, both to the horse world itself and the general public.
“That’s absolutely paramount,” said Kezia Allen of the British Horse Foundation (BHF) “It’s fundamental at the BHF, making that education accessible to everyone. We all want to do the best by our horses, so it’s incumbent on us all to do the research, get the evidence and present it to every yard in a way people can understand and implement.”
Mr Owers cautioned against the “it’s antis on social media” view, adding that there have been a number of horse-related issues that have gone viral in the last year, and that we must communicate the many positives of the horse-human partnership, to both parties.
“The key is looking at it through the lens of the public, not the horse world,” he said. “Not talking down to people, but ensuring we’re clear on the benefits of the partnership. It can’t be equal, but we can make it as equal as possible.”
Mr Owers added that it does not matter to the public which discipline it is – eventing, racing, dressage or modern pentathlon are all “people riding horses” to the public.
Ms Iggulden agreed, adding: “Horse sport needs joined-up thinking about the answers to difficult questions, to participants and the public.”
Asked whether the number of UK governing bodies makes this harder, Mr Owers said no, as although coordination and consistency is so important, each discipline has different issues.
“Of course, there are things relevant to all; the three Fs of friends, forage and freedom apply to racehorses as much as dressage horses, and I think it’s a collective responsibility. All disciplines have to play their part. It’s so damaging when people say lovely words but do nothing; we have to walk the talk.”
- What do you think we can do to maintain our social licence? Send your thoughts to firstname.lastname@example.org, including your name, nearest town and country, and you could win a bottle of Champagne Taittinger
You might also be interested in:
Horse & Hound magazine, out every Thursday, is packed with all the latest news and reports, as well as interviews, specials, nostalgia, vet and training advice. Find how you can enjoy the magazine delivered to your door every week, plus options to upgrade your subscription to access our online service that brings you breaking news and reports as well as other benefits.