If you’re not aware of Cooley Nutcracker yet, put him on your radar. The 10-year-old has won both his CCI4*-L starts and is currently equal third after dressage in the five-star at the Defender Kentucky Three-Day Event.
“He’s gorgeous, I absolutely love him. He’s one of my favourite horses,” said his rider Liz Halliday after his test yesterday. “He’s incredibly sharp, which nobody realises because they see me on him and close to him, but he’s very people sharp, horse sharp, everything – but I think that’s what makes him so good and so careful.”
Liz continues: “He’s interesting because he’ll go and spook in the warm-up and spook along when he goes in the showjumping ring, but once he’s on on the job, he’s all business, which I love about him. He loves to compete. And he’s just a powerhouse, he’s got a lot of engine.”
The black gelding was bred in Ireland by Gary Doherty, by Tolan R. He was produced by French Olympic medallist Astier Nicolas up to three-star level, competing with him in the seven-year-old World Championships before joining Liz in 2022.
Liz says that the two of them “becoming friends over the last two years” has been an essential part of their success.
“I think it’s just stepping stones to a big future for him because I really believe in him a lot,” she said.
The pair earned a good smattering of eights in their dressage test, with the marks dropping down when the syndicate owned horse showed his inexperience in the walk and the flying changes. Their final score was 30.6, to sit alongside Lauren Nicholson and the veteran fan favourite Vermiculus.
Horse & Hound Newsletter
Never miss out on the latest happenings in the equestrian world
“He’s still a bit weak and with plenty of green moments, I’m thrilled with the score he got because it just shows what he’s going to be. It wasn’t even close to a polished test,” said Liz. “He’s capable of low 20s. He’s had that in four-stars, he just needs to get a little more solidified in his changes and more calm and relaxed in the ring, and then I think he’ll be spectacular.
“When he’s nervous, he suddenly tries to stop on me. That was what he did in the first shoulder-in and so I rode him quite strong in the second one. He also does it sometimes going across the diagonal to change without me doing anything – He just goes, ‘How about I walk?’ so I’m saying, ‘No, please don’t walk.’
“He did notice the camera in the extended walk, but he was a very good boy to go whoa and just put himself back together again and be a professional. So I was proud of him for that.”
Looking ahead to today’s cross-country, Liz said she always believed Cooley Nutcracker would be a five-star horse and that he is “incredibly brave”, but it was only halfway round Galway Downs in the autumn last year that she thought he was ready for the challenge.
“He jumps very big and he’s very careful. I needed him to measure the jumps better, not jump so high and there he just measured all the drops into water and I thought, ‘Now he’s ready’,” she said.
“I actually think it’ll be great for him for me to just let him gallop. He has an incredible gallop, he is quite a keen ride cross-country. I like the beginning of the course for him – that there are fences you can just ride up to which I think will be great to settle him in.”
The pair head out across country at 3.22pm (8.22pm British time).
Enjoy the best of Kentucky with Horse & Hound
To ensure you keep up to date with all the breaking news, behind the scenes insight, and the best of the action throughout Kentucky Three-Day Event with no limits on how much you can read, subscribe to the Horse & Hound website from £1 a week in the UK or less than $2 a week in the US. Sign up now. And don’t miss our Kentucky Three-Day Event magazine report in the issue of Horse & Hound dated 3 May.
Stay in touch with all the news in the run-up to and throughout the major shows and events during 2026 and beyond with a Horse & Hound subscription. Subscribe today for all you need to know ahead of these major events, plus online reports on the action as it happens from our expert team of reporters and in-depth analysis in our special commemorative magazines. Have a subscription already? Set up your unlimited website access now
Pippa is a true eventing geek and has been H&H’s eventing editor since 2005. She has first-hand experience of competing up to British Eventing intermediate and international CCI2*-L level, and has worked in the industry on a top event yard. Pippa enjoys nothing more than immersing herself in the sport at the highest level, reporting from the five-stars and international championships, including the Olympics.
