Alamy Live News. 2XMKAR6 28th July 2024; Paris Olympic Games, Paris, France, Day 3; Equestrian team and individual cross country at Versailles palace, Rosalind Canter of Great Britain in action during the cross country This is an Alamy Live News image and may not be part of your current Alamy deal . If you are unsure, please contact our sales team to check.
FEI field-of-play rules have come under discussion following recent cases in eventing.
H&H reported that Lithuanian rider Aistis Vitkauskas lost his individual Olympic place when he was unable to obtain his final minimum eligibility requirement at Luhmühlen, as he was eliminated across country under the dangerous riding rule (news, 11 July). Aistis disagreed with the ground jury’s decision, but as this was a field-of-play ruling, it was not subject to appeal.
“We were absolutely over the moon with Ros and we had no idea about the 15 penalties,” he said. “It is no secret that we pushed it, we appealed it, we went as far as we could with it. But unfortunately it’s a field-of-play decision and the ground jury weren’t budging and they wouldn’t budge with anyone else’s penalties.”
Under the FEI general regulations, protests may be lodged against any person or body involved in an international event or otherwise subject to the jurisdiction of the FEI including for failure to observe the statutes, general regulations or sport rules, or violation of the common principles of behaviour, fairness, or accepted standards of sportsmanship.
Horse & Hound Newsletter
Never miss out on the latest happenings in the equestrian world
But the rules state that there is no protest against ground jury decisions arising from the field of play, “which are final and binding”. These decisions can include, but are not limited to, when the decision is based on a factual observation, whether an obstacle was knocked down, the time taken for the round, whether a horse circled, refused or ran out.
The FEI confirmed to H&H that even if the rules state that a matter such as a field-of-play decision is not subject to protest, national federations can still choose to file a protest for consideration by the ground jury.
“They may raise an issue regarding the processes that were applied in reaching the field-of-play decision (for example, application of the wrong rule or some other procedural defect in the process) that could potentially lead to the protest being upheld, however this is rare,” said an FEI spokesperson.
“The jurisprudence of the Court of Arbitration for Sport on field-of-play decisions is clear and such decisions are only overturned if there is evidence of bad faith, arbitrariness or bias.”
Kate Rocher-Smith was incorrectly given 71 penalties at Pau five-star last October – when she only incurred 31. It was recorded that Kate had two refusals and activated a MIM clip at a fence, when she only had one refusal and the MIM clip. She retired at this fence after knocking herself on the horse’s neck, causing her to sustain a concussion.
When Kate asked the FEI for the horse’s record to be amended, she was told no and it was treated as a field-of-play decision. She was also told she should have objected to the results within 30 minutes of the results being published, but owing to Kate’s concussion, she did not see the results until days later.
After reviewing the video footage, the FEI agreed to give Kate a letter confirming that the scoring was incorrect – but would not update her official record. Kate appealed to the FEI tribunal, but on 14 June her case was ruled “inadmissible” as the tribunal does not have jurisdiction over field-of-play decisions, which are considered “non-appealable”.
Kate told H&H the decision was “disappointing”.
“Riders work hard, and competition results are incredibly valuable. I can understand that you can’t have people a month later saying they didn’t have a pole down – but there needs to be set ways of checking things. You cannot record things inaccurately, and you should be able to dispute this,” she said.
To stay up to date with all the breaking news throughout the Paralympic Games, Burghley, Horse of the Year Show and more, subscribe to the Horse & Hound website
Stay in touch with all the news in the run-up to and throughout the major shows and events during 2026 and beyond with a Horse & Hound subscription. Subscribe today for all you need to know ahead of these major events, plus online reports on the action as it happens from our expert team of reporters and in-depth analysis in our special commemorative magazines. Have a subscription already? Set up your unlimited website access now
Since joining H&H in 2018, Becky has covered a broad range of equestrian news including welfare matters, veterinary studies, FEI Tribunal hearings and road safety campaigns. She has also interviewed top riders including Scott Brash, John Whitaker and Ian Stark, to name just a few. Becky’s reporting has taken her to Canada for Spruce Meadows and France for Pau five-star, as well as the Royal Highland and Blair Castle International Horse Trials closer to home. She was also a key part of the remote reporting team for the Tokyo Olympics and the Europeans.
