FALL FALLS THRILLS AND SPILLS Dee Hankey (GBR)&Chequer's Playboy fall at the DHL Water Complex - Cross Country - Luhmuhlen CCI4* - Salzhausen, Germany - 14 June 2013
Cross-country falls are more likely to occur at four-star and championship events, and to involve less experienced riders, according to recent statistics.
An eventing audit report was undertaken by Charles Barnett, formerly of Aintree and Ascot racecourses, and findings were presented at the FEI general assembly last week (13 November).
The data analysed was from 1,180 falls from 76,638 cross-country starts between July 2010 and December 2014.
The information was taken from horse registrations, rider registrations, technical delegates and fence judges.
“The idea was to track trends and to make suggestions about gathering data,” said Charles.
“There is no single, easy fix to prevent falls. There are a number of factors that can help reduce falls and we will make some recommendations [see below].
“Eventing is a risk sport. We will never be able to eradicate accidents, so we must have a robust plan to deal with the view from the public if they do occur.”
Horse & Hound Newsletter
Never miss out on the latest happenings in the equestrian world
The number of falls is greater at a higher level, and they generally feature less experience riders.
“Better riders are half as likely to fall as non-categorised riders,” said Charles. “Are we allowing riders who are not proficient enough to take part in three- and four-star events?” he asked.
“You are 3.5% more likely to see a fall at four-star or championships than at one-star. Is it because the competition tougher at championships so riders go to the limit? Or is it the effect of riding on a team?”
(Image credit: creditUnknown)
‘Surprise’ of frangible result
Types of fences were also discussed — with open corners causing fewer falls than closed, while falls were greater when the obstacle involved water. Downhill jumps were also problematic.
However, footing was one area that was not looked at.
Analysis also showed that there was an increased risk of a fall at fences with frangible pins.
“Frangibles were designed to reduce falls, so the fact they threw up more was surprising, but this needs looking into further. It seems odd to us that breakable fences had more falls,” said Charles.
British Eventing (BE)’s Jonathan Clissold told H&H: “Of the 105 falls at frangible elements, 4% were somersault falls.
“This is considerably fewer than the 11% that occurred at non-frangible fences, which suggests that frangible fences are providing some safety benefit to riders.
“However, due to the small sample size of falls at frangible elements, caution should be taken when interpreting this result.”
New Zealand eventer Bruce Haskell added: “If there’s been a fall but the frangible prevented rotation and saved someone’s life then it’s done its job.”
(Image credit: creditUnknown)
Putting action in place
Eventing committee chair and course-designer Giuseppe Della Chiesa said it is “important to have an outside view”.
“Many of the conclusions are not surprising, but confirm the commitment to limiting the risk. Many suggestions we are already implementing and many more we will take on board for the future,” he added.
However, Bruce Haskell warned that you need to be “very careful” when interpreting statistics.
“I’m concerned it doesn’t take into account lesser nations,” he said. “However, having concrete results will make course-designers more aware and should make the sport safer — if it impacts how they design courses and, in turn, how courses are tackled by riders.”
Charles Barnett added that more analysis was to be undertaken.
Recommendations from Charles Barnett
There is a strong argument to restrict the top events to the best riders
Standardise entry requirements around the world to make analysis easier
Consider having another category of rider, or a rider licence to have greater control of competition and testing
Stay in touch with all the news in the run-up to and throughout the major shows and events during 2026 and beyond with a Horse & Hound subscription. Subscribe today for all you need to know ahead of these major events, plus online reports on the action as it happens from our expert team of reporters and in-depth analysis in our special commemorative magazines. Have a subscription already? Set up your unlimited website access now
A graduate of Exeter University, Amy joined our news team from Redpin Publishing in 2008 as news writer. She was promoted to deputy news editor in May 2013 and became news editor in April 2015. She left Horse & Hound in March 2016 to take up an editorial position in Dubai.
