Show horse producer Simon Reynolds believed rising costs is forcing competitors to make more selective decisions with greater pressure to deliver results at every outing
Behind the scenes, a challenge is growing that could shape the future of the sport. It is no secret that equestrianism is under increasing strain, whether through social licence concerns, equine welfare scrutiny, or financial pressure.
The true cost of producing a horse to the top level has escalated sharply. For some, this is no longer manageable; it is a tipping point. Fuel strikes planned last week and crippling fuel prices served as a reminder of how external pressures are becoming the everyday reality of competing.
Competitors are making more selective decisions. Fewer shows, fewer horses, and greater pressure to deliver results at every outing. The margin for “giving a horse time” is narrowing.
Competitors may perceive that every entry fee and mile travelled must justify itself. The question is whether a once pleasure-driven sport could turn into something more calculated, and potentially more ruthless.
Decisions around campaigning frequency, recovery time and when a horse is truly ready for the ring deserve careful thought. With competition becoming a calculation rather than a progression, there is a risk that welfare could come under pressure. Expectations may, in some cases, be shaped by cost rather than readiness.
Of course, the very best producers and owners will never compromise their horses, but it would be naive to assume the wider system is immune.
We must also recognise the structure that underpins these competitions. The sport and shows rely heavily on volunteers. Rising costs are affecting shows just as they are competitors. Some early season events have reported lower entries, while fixed costs continue to climb. There are also murmurs of poor competitor behaviour; when the cost of attending is high, expectations rise.
While this does not reflect the majority, it takes very little to tip the balance.
Are “classic” types in danger?
Alongside this, another shift is taking place, one that raises concern that traditional breeding and correct types are being diluted. Particularly in show hack classes – although it is also evident in hunter ranks – we are seeing a move away from the thoroughbred type towards more of a Continental look, threatening the profile of the classic show hack of the past.
Today’s horse owner often seeks versatility, a horse that can show, but also turn a hoof to dressage or other disciplines. Breeders are following the sport horse market rather than producing specialist types. Many Continentally bred horses offer trainability and rideability.
Yet this raises an important question: does showing now reward “off the floor” movement over the correct type? Type is evolving, and even riding attire is reflecting this with a move away from its understated heritage.
Showing may soon face a defining question: do we hold the line on what constitutes a true hack or traditional hunter, or accept an evolution towards a sport-influenced animal? Do enough of these classic horses even exist?
Encouragingly, tradition is still being championed. I am delighted that the Irish Draught classes continue to draw strong numbers, with their Royal International qualifiers often among the best supported sections. Alongside the thoroughbred, this breed remains vital.
Yet the future is far from bleak. It is encouraging to see a new generation of talented probationary judges emerging, including much needed side-saddle specialists. Showing needs these judges.
As some ride judges retire, there is a clear requirement to support those stepping forward. With experienced judge mentorship, this will build knowledge, confidence, and consistency for the future.
The sport may be under pressure, but it is also evolving. The challenge is to adapt without losing the values and traditions that define it.
● What measures do you think could be put in place to safeguard type and tradition in the show ring? We’d love to hear from you at hhletters@futurenet.com, including your name, nearest town and county, for the chance to have your thoughts published in a future issue of Horse & Hound magazine
- To stay up to date with all the breaking news from major events, as well as exclusive insights from top names, subscribe to the Horse & Hound website
You might also enjoy reading:
Showing producer banned for eight years after video goes viral said he ‘takes horse welfare extremely seriously’
A competitor’s guide to the 2026 HOYS showing qualifiers – including judges and closing dates
Marking systems in showing – their benefits, flaws and what the future may be
Subscribe to Horse & Hound magazine today – and enjoy unlimited website access all year round
