Fall was an accident, rules judge
An ex-model and businesswoman, who suffered head injuries in what she described as a “life-changing” fall from a horse while taking a riding lesson, today had her hopes of massive compensation dashed.
Mr Justice Openshaw rejected 48-year-old Catherine MacClancy’s claim that a low branch hit or distracted her as she tackled a drop jump at a riding stables in the Cotswolds.
And he vindicated Jillian Carenza, 55, who owns The Vine Riding and Livery Yard, near Broadway, Worcestershire, ruling she could in no way be blamed for the June 2003 tragedy. Dismissing Ms MacClancy’s six-figure damages claim, the judge said: “Riding, particularly riding in open country, is not free of risk.
“Of course, an instructor must take steps to reduce the risk to what is reasonable and acceptable; I find that the defendant (Ms Carenza) did just that.
“I am acutely aware of the dreadful effect that this accident has had upon the claimant (Miss MacClancy), but I find that it was just that: an accident.”
Read industry reaction to this ruling >>
For exclusive full industry reaction to the ruling see next Thursday’s issue of Horse & Hound (22 March)
Never miss out on the latest happenings in the equestrian world
Stay in touch with all the news in the run-up to and throughout the major shows and events during 2026 and beyond with a Horse & Hound subscription. Subscribe today for all you need to know ahead of these major events, plus online reports on the action as it happens from our expert team of reporters and in-depth analysis in our special commemorative magazines. Have a subscription already? Set up your unlimited website access now
