Most riders have stood at the side of the arena, test sheet in hand, trying to work out what the dressage judge’s comments actually mean. Sometimes it’s the handwriting that’s the challenge. More often, it’s the comment itself.
Turning a five-word remark into something useful to work on at home isn’t always straightforward, especially if you’re new to the sport. A note such as “needs more engagement” or “lacks balance” can feel frustratingly vague when what you really want is clear direction.
It’s worth remembering that judges aren’t there to coach you. Their job is to assess what they see in that moment and mark it against the directives for each movement. With limited space and time, their comments have to be brief and to the point.
I’ve had the questionable honour of reading hundreds of test sheets over the years. While I can’t help you decipher a hurried scrawl from a fading biro, I can translate some of the most common phrases and explain what they usually mean for your dressage training at home.
Before diving in, keep this in mind: most comments relate to one of three things – the horse’s way of going (rhythm, suppleness, contact, impulsion, straightness, collectively known as scales of training), test accuracy (hitting your markers and riding the correct shapes), or cooperation (what would’ve previously been described as submission). If you can identify which category the remark falls into, it becomes much easier to know what to work on.
Judges assess what they see in that moment and mark it against the directives for each movement.
Way of going
Needs more suppleness
Suppleness comes from being even on both reins and bending through the body without resistance. If the horse feels stiffer one way, falls out through a shoulder or resists a change of bend, that unevenness will show in the mark.
Losing balance
Often, this means the horse is falling onto the inside shoulder, particularly on circles or in lateral work. You may notice the tempo change or the line drift. Often the horse isn’t carrying enough weight behind to stay organised.
Lacking or losing rhythm
Rhythm is the regularity of the footfall. Walk should stay clearly four-beat, trot two-beat, canter three-beat. If the steps become hurried, uneven or tense, the score will drop.
Irregular
A comment no one wants to see. Judges use “irregular” rather than “lame” if a horse appears momentarily unlevel. Even a brief loss of regularity affects the mark.
Needs more energy or impulsion
Impulsion is controlled pushing power from the hindquarters. It does not mean faster. It means more active, engaged steps that create lift and presence within the correct tempo.
Behind the leg
The horse isn’t reacting promptly to the leg aid. They may feel sluggish, or run onto the forehand instead of stepping through correctly.
Inconsistent to the contact
Contact should be soft, elastic and steady. If the connection changes from stride to stride – behind the bit, above it, fussy in the mouth – the judge will see a lack of acceptance.
Against the hand
The horse is resisting the contact. They may lift their head, snatch at the reins or lean heavily. Often this is linked to tension or imbalance.
Behind the vertical
The nose is carried behind the vertical line from the poll. This can stem from tension, loss of balance or too much hand.
Above the bit or hollow
The horse lifts their head and drops their back away from the contact. The outline looks disconnected rather than through and supple.
Straightness
A horse is straight when the hind feet follow the forefeet on straight lines, and the body matches the curve on circles. Comments such as “quarters in”, “crooked” or “on two tracks” all point to a loss of alignment.
Could be more uphill
A classic – too much weight is being carried on the shoulders. The horse may rush or struggle to maintain fluency because he isn’t sitting enough behind.
Needs more ground cover
The strides are too short. In medium paces or free walk, the horse isn’t clearly lengthening and stepping through enough to cover more ground.
Needs to show more difference
The judge wants a clearer contrast between working and medium paces. If the horse simply quickens rather than truly lengthens, this comment appears.
Running
Instead of lengthening the stride, the horse has increased the tempo. More speed, not more reach.
Needs to flow more freely forwards
The movement looks restricted. The horse may be tight through the back, behind the leg or lacking confidence to travel forward.
Understanding common phrases makes it possible to adapt your training at home. Credit: Emma Herrod Photography
Accuracy
Circle not round/loops not even/not centred
The shape or placement of the movement wasn’t correct. Even with a good way of going, inaccurate geometry will cost marks.
Halt not square or immobility not maintained
In halt, the horse should stand balanced and square, then remain still. A resting hindleg or fidgeting lowers the score.
Cooperation
Submission or acceptance of the aids
Often used interchangeably, the submission comment isn’t about dominance. Spooking, resistance, tension or ignoring the leg can all be reflected in this mark.
Still unsure what the comment means?
If you’re still unsure what a comment means, look back at the directive for that movement in the test. Ask yourself: was the judge marking the way of going, accuracy, or cooperation? Do that, and a cryptic five-word remark becomes a clear schooling goal.
- Enjoyed reading this? For more expert training advice from top riders and coaches, subscribe to the Horse & Hound website
You may also be interested in:
Fancy trying affiliated dressage, but not quite sure where to start? You need to read this…
Struggling to learn and remember your dressage test? Here’s the secret to success…
7 things you wanted to know about affiliated dressage but were too embarrassed to ask
23 of the most embarrassing comments we’ve ever seen on a dressage sheet
From hors concours to middle tour – 14 confusing dressage terms explained
Pammy Hutton: ‘Judging dressage really is a devil of a job’
Subscribe to Horse & Hound magazine today – and enjoy unlimited website access all year round
