You are here: Home / Articles / News
Report claims no scientific grounds for hunting ban
18 August, 2007
January Sale! Subscribe to Horse & Hound and save up to 35% today
The ban on hunting with dogs has no scientific grounds, according to a recent report from the All Party Parliamentary Middle Way Group and the Veterinary Association for Wildlife Management (VAWM).
The Use, Misuse and Abuse of Science, released on 27 July, claims that the government, media and public were “duped by fake and twisted science” provided by anti-hunting groups in the run up to the ban in February 2005.
According to the report, “the large body of scientific evidence” cited by the RSPCA simply does not exist.
The government-commissioned Burns Report, published in June 2000, comes under scrutiny for seeking to justify the ban on grounds of cruelty, although in a 2004 speech in the Lords, its author Lord Burns admitted “there is insufficient verifiable evidence to reach views about cruelty”.
This report further discredits the Burns Report because it does not allow for the animal escaping with a fatal wound.
The report also claims some items of research such as A Veterinary Opinion on Hunting with Hounds by Thomas and Allen were ignored. This document represented 300 vets and concluded that hunting constituted the most humane method of control.
Dr Lewis Thomas of the VAWM said: “I understand this was ignored because it was based on opinion instead of fact. But why, when they were listening to the opinion of anti-hunting professors?”
The new report also points out that the only peer-reviewed scientific study into wounding in shot foxes (published in the Universities Federation for Animal Welfare in its journal Animal Welfare, in May 2005) was largely ignored by MPs.
Dr Thomas said he hoped the report would allow politicians motivated to repeal the ban “to have sound information to support their cause”.
This news story was first published in Horse & Hound (16 August, '07)
Related articles:
- Putting a plaster cast on a horse's broken leg
- Film is a positive step forwards in promoting hunting
- More foxes being killed in Scotland than before the ban
- LACS chief spinner arrested over expenses fraud
- H&H readers urged to help with sweet itch survey
- Teaching children to love hunting
- Farewell to hunting and pointing stalwart Alan Armstrong
- What next for the Countryside Alliance's "Lady Godiva"?
- Tests reveal Tim Stockdale's injuries greater than first thought
- Fernie huntsman loses appeal against hunting conviction